Dread is useful as a highly improvised one-shot party or pickup game. I prefer Fiasco if people are clear-headed and RPG-minded, but for Halloween and the less-than-sober, Dread is the perfect RPG. All you need is a Jenga tower and scenario.
The scenario is the tricky part. Dread provides some prewritten scenarios, but they’re trying too hard to be useful. They’re thorough, thoughtful, and well designed, but that’s not what Dread needs. Dread tends to be almost entirely improvised. It's a game that's on the borderline of being a freeform acting exercise. It is excellent for sharpening a GM's skills, but there is no safety net. No rules, no notes, no higher authority.
Someone could run Dread as their first RPG. The book is full of good advice. If the GM had a theatre or improv background, or watched a lot of RPG content, or were lucky and talented, it could work reasonably well. But for an experienced GM, someone who understands pace of play and spotlight time, who’s willing to invent rules on the fly, who can draw out reticent players, who can paint a scene in a few words... Dread is still difficult. It’s an improvised solo in front of a critical audience. It strips away all the comforting safety nets a GM usually has and says “OK, hot shot, let’s see you do it on the high wire."
Running
Dread at a party is a bit like breaking out a guitar. Plinking out “Smoke on
the Water” won’t cut it. But it's a lot more fun than a Jackbox game or some fiddly board game with a pristine cardboard chits.
Vincenzo Lamolinara
The Dread rulebook is 96 pages long. It is well worth the price, but the core rules of
Dread could fit on an index card with room to spare. It’s a victim of its own simple
brilliance.
Since the rules and quickstart are free, here’s a summary.
-One GM (skilled), 3-6 players (no skill or previous RPG knowledge required). Fewer than 3 players and the resolution mechanic doesn’t work; more than 6 and it gets unwieldy to reach across a table.
-The GM sets a scenario, theme, and goes over any safety tools they’re using.
-Players create character concepts.
-GM calls on a player to pull from a Jenga tower whenever a player attempts something perilous, or whenever they feel like increasing the tension. Basically, any time the GM thinks that a horror movie death could occur, a player should pull. The harder the task, the more pulls may be required, potentially with each pull representing a different stage or aspect of the task.
-Successful pull = danger avoided. Knock over tower = character dies (or is otherwise out of the game). Abandon pull = failure with consequences but not character death. Deliberately knock over tower = character succeeds at a fatal cost.
-If the tower is knocked over, rebuild it with 3 blocks already pulled for each time it has fallen this game.
That’s the game (or most of it). But don't mistake "simple" for "easy."
Optional Houserules
Use a few or none at all. Sourced from reddit, Smosh plays Dread, and testing.
-Heroic Intervention. If a player is pulling from the tower, another player who has a character in the scene may knock the tower over, sacrificing their character to save the character of the pulling player. This is in addition to The Sacrifice rule, where the pulling player may deliberately knock over the tower to succeed at a fatal cost.
-Betrayal. If a player would pull from the tower, once per game, their character may betray another player’s character who is in the scene. That player must pull instead.
-Time Limits. Instead of just adjusting the number of pulls, require 2 pulls in 30 seconds, 4 pulls in 1 minute, etc. Works well with a thematic timer (hourglass, ominous buzzer, flickering digital clock).
-Physical Damage. If a player abandons a pull and, as a result of the subsequent failure, suffers an injury, that injury affects their ability on future pulls. The player must use their non-dominant hand, cover one eye, etc.
-Telegraphed Jumpscare. Dread says not to use jumpscares, and it is correct, but one consequence of an abandoned pull could be a warning that, during some future pull by that player, there may be a jumpscare. If the GM can secretly set it up so that another player (possibly of a dead character) or a bystander can deliver the scare on cue, the results tend to be tremendous.
-Coloured or Marked Blocks. If the tower has multiple colours or other distinct markings, the GM can call for a pull of a specific colour (or randomize which colour must be pulled).
Rules Not To Use
Elective
pulls (pg. 14)
I don’t
think these are required. Dread is a heavily GM-mediated game. Players can ask
if their characters can do something, but they can’t ask to do something
mechanical. The sense of dread only works if their ultimate fate feels out of
their hands. No elective pulls, no making the situation easier mechanically, no
direct interaction with the rules. Just draw when told to draw.
Pre-pulls
for <5 player groups (pg.7)
I think these are unnecessary. The pristine tower at the start of the game, and its eventual appalling state, is part of the charm of Dread. The GM should
just call for multiple pulls early. Use a fast-paced deadly opening/prologue followed by a more normal period of tension-building. It’s probably fine if you’re using Dread’s
resolution mechanism in a more standard type of RPG session.
Dead and Bored
Dread's main drawback, like many high-lethality systems, is that a character can die early, giving the player nothing to do for some time. This is ameliorated by a party atmosphere; there's usually something else going on. It also allows initially hesitant or skeptical viewers to jump in.
Some GMs suggest a "fated to die" approach, where the character of a player that causes the tower to topple is doomed in the final scene, but will survive until then. This, I feel, misses the point of Dread. It is not a merciful system designed to tell many types of stories.
The GM does need to learn to eyeball the tower's current state, and manage the pace of play accordingly. Dread works best at ~2-2.5 hours. The pace of play has to be blistering.
Schemes and Survival
RPGs rely on schemes. A setting that does not encourage schemes is a sterile and joyless affair. But in Dread, there is no escape. The characters are doomed by default. Success is not making it to the end of the scenario by block-pulling dexterity, rules manipulation, and smart planning. Success is if the resulting story is good (and frightening). There has to be a willingness to go "oh darn" when a character's carefully planned escape goes awry in an arbitrary way, a desire to survive mixed with a knowledge of the nature of the genre.
In a conventional RPG, a player building a backpack-mounted weed-killer sprayer to push back the Kuzdu from Mars is doing a good job. That sort of scheme should be encouraged, and it should work. But in Dread, if they do that, pull, and topple the tower... then the GM can reveal that Mayor Pondrick was too cheap to buy actual weed killer, and told the groundskeeper to use apple cider vinegar instead. "But I did everything riiiiiight," the character cries, as the Kuzdu devours them. 
Ben J
Character Creation
Dread has a very thorough questionnaire system. No doubt, when used properly, it would help players generate very interesting interlinked characters. But Dread is rarely run as a proper game. It is a throw-it-together-and-run game, a game you can run with only a Jenga tower. No paper, no pencils, no dice, no frontal lobes. And this means the players, who may be new to RPGs, intoxicated, leaving in half an hour, etc. will not fill out a detailed questionnaire.
The GM should, instead, start with an elevator pitch, before setup, while wrangling players away from the snacks and towards the table. They should provide basic setting and tone info, with lots of tropes, giving players obvious hooks for character creation.
Example. “It’s early October, 1957. The Russians have just put an artificial moon called Sputnik in orbit. You and some other youths from the small town of Sunbeam, Illinois have gathered on Makeout Ridge to watch it.”
GM may, depending on the scenario, wish to prepare a list of character concepts. These should be extremely basic. Just a name (because names are hard) and a few words, like a High Concept from Fate. These are backup options for players who are stuck on a concept, confused, joining the game late, etc.
Examples: Kurt Mallory. Greaser, rough but heart of gold. Deborah Shankie, part-time waitress, wants out of town. Maria Shankie, younger sister who snuck out. Peter McCormick, varsity-jacketed quarterback. Al Fontaine, hobo veteran, just passing through. Janet Vansavian, wannabe reporter. Dan Haskap, kid with paper route and slingshot. Frank Biswas, new student in town. Deputy Dan, wide open mind. Rusty, the dog.
If backstories are required, they can be invented during play. Put some faith in your players.
Pencils and paper are not required, but names are hard. It's sometimes handy to write the character’s name on both sides of a piece of bent cardstock, to make a place card. A standard Jenga box is wide enough to slip a stack of notecards down the side.
 |
| SMBC |
Minimum Viable Scenarios
All a GM needs to craft a game... at maximum effort. Don't spend your time writing down notes and plans. Spend your time assembling mental lists of tropes, characters, scenarios, hazards, etc. The game lives in your brain, not on paper. Be prepared to pivot immediately.
You can use Dread to test ideas that might not be worth a full module or screenplay. If a concept or twist doesn't work, the stakes are low.
Criteria:
-Ensemble
cast. Story has to handle multiple characters. No main character. No peril that can only be faced alone.
-Easy and
comprehensible elevator pitch.
-Easy to
think of moments of deadly peril
-Easy for
low-investment players to generate character concepts.
Standard Sci-Fi / Horror
Alien Invasion
Flying saucers, ray
guns, skeptical sheriffs, disembowelled cattle, etc. One of the easiest
scenarios to twist; one of the hardest to make truly frightening.
The Backrooms
There’s a weird
inexplicable environment that kills you. Reality is breaking down. Difficult to
do well, but very satisfying, especially if there are moments of normality in
between episodes of profound theatre-of-the-mind weirdness.
The Blob
An unstoppable
non-sapient alien threat, possibly with a weakness. Works best with specific
geography in mind.
Bloody Mary
The characters performed
a ritual and now something (an urban legend, a ghost, the devil) is coming for
them. An isolated setting is not required; most people simply won't believe it. The ritual could be a science experiment.
Event Horizon
There’s an abandoned ship and it’s haunted or infested. Characters are your
standard crew tropes. Works on the water. Could be an abandoned hospital, but
we’re starting to get into Old Dark House territory.
Final Destination
A group of people
survive a deadly event via a premonition, and death wants to kill them via
implausible events. Can be a thin scenario without a complication (e.g. on
vacation, theme park, in space, etc.). Doesn’t work particularly well as a
Dread scenario; arbitrary and nigh-inevitable death is a core part of Dread
anyway. I’ve included it because if I didn’t, I’m sure the comments would
suggest it.
Jurassic Park
An island full of deadly creatures. An old guy in a panama suit tells you he’s
spared no expense on his quest to clone giant trilobites or the Beatles. Or the island is just like that naturally.
The Old Dark House
There’s an inn or a
manor and the bridge is washed out. There’s something in the walls, someone in
the attic, a sound on the moors. All the lights go out and someone has to start
the generator.
Slasher
There’s a guy with a knife and he’s after you. Replace [guy], [knife], etc. Could be an alien on a spaceship, a robot from
the future, a Dracula, a Werewolf, etc. Isolated
settings are best, unless you can come up with a good reason for it to work in
a crowd (e.g. it’s halloween, it can teleport, etc.)
Strangers in Town
The car broke down or you’re on vacation. There are cultists, cannibals,
witches, billionaires, Soviet infiltrators, psychic children, etc. Folk horror.
Tiny
You’re mice or rabbits or shrunken people. The world is red in tooth and claw.
The Violent Unknown Event
A polite public-service-announcement apocalypse. Paranoia-style absurdity. Remain indoors, obey all posted signs, disobey all false signs.
Your Worst Job
A highly specific personal horror story. Any bad job you’ve worked, but suddenly
worse. Stephen King used this a lot.
Zombies
Too many variants to cover. Everyone has gone insane and wants to kill you. Could be the Purge, with guns, or alien doppelgangers, or chemical weapons. 
Flavio Greco Paglia
Non-Horror Examples
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
The [Stuff]
Factory (or even The Stuff Factory) is always good. Players generate
children+vice (parent optional).
The Titanic
There’s a big ship
and it is sinking. Could also be called The
Poseidon Adventure. Really, a “get from here to there in a dangerous
artificial environment.” Could be space, underwater, etc.
Disaster
There’s an earthquake, volcano, hurricane, tornado, hailstorm, thunderstorm,
tsunami, blackout, whiteout, or asteroid. The great thing about RPGs is that
the special effects budget is unlimited.
The Seven Samurai
We need a specific
number of misfits to defend a village against bandits and their leader.
Example Notecard
I may have lied a little bit about not prepping for Dread. I tend to write down scenario ideas on a card, then leave it in my pocket during game. These notes approach "man door hand hook car door" levels of terseness.
October 4 1957 Sputnik launch Oct 7 game. Watching it western sky. Orbits once 90 mins. Beeps 1.5x per sec. Sunbeam, IL. Evening. Teenagers. Radio rebroadcast of beeps. "WKRU Radio, and we're OK. Are you?" Clouds with gaps. Nearly midnight. Stars are out. Moving star. Then, as the clouds close, another. And another. A triangle of them, like a flock of geese. Radio picking up another signal, 210 megacycles, rebroadcast. Beeps rising. Car lights flicker. Turn off, first pull. Car broken, carpool into town. Streetlights off. Things in the sky. Job 38. Mad minister. Noises above clouds. Stop. Plane, parked in field by roadside, engine still turning, baking hot. Fishing boat. Called down by radio station, on the road to Pikeville. Angels in sputnik's image. Sky rolled up like a scroll. Moving through wires.
The more prep you do, the more props and soundboards you use, the more you'll wish you had all the tools a more detailed system offers. Dread is perfect as an exercise in minimalism.
 |
| Aleksandr Nikonov |
Final Notes
Dread delivers experiences that Betrayal at House on the Hill etc. promise. Board games require no particular skills beyond reading comprehension and a bit of tactical thinking. They promise a high-effort experience without cost, and usually fail, because imitation effort substitute never tastes as good as the real thing. Dread has a high skill requirement for the GM, but when it works, it really works.
